Nekesa Mumbi Moody makes a rather weak case in defense of Ashlee Simpson by suggesting that lip synching has always been rampant in popular music and presenting the following examples as evidence:
- Now-classic footage from shows like "American Bandstand" featured artists lip-synching.
- Michael Jackson mouthed part of his superstar-making moment on the "Motown 25" TV show in 1983.
- Whitney Houston's spine-chilling rendition of "The Star-Spangled Banner" at the 1991 Super Bowl was prerecorded.
- And perhaps the only moments when Britney Spears did not lip-synch during her recent tour was when she said hello and goodbye to her audience.
Actually, Britney's hello and goodbye
were prerecorded. Seriously though, I feel that Moody misses the whole point here. None of these shows actually
feature live music. These programs exist to plug a product; in Whitney's case, the product is democracy.
We as a nation are not only taking this opportunity to attack Ashlee, but also what she stands for: the corporate celebrity machine posing as music.
Saturday Night Live, a program that once featured artists such as Sun Ra, The Preservation Hall Jazz Band and Captain Beefheart, now has its "musical" segment sponsored by Budweiser and exclusively features boring corporate rock and hip hop acts.
Saturday Night Live is a shadow of its former self, that must be said, but outting a single program only obscures the symptoms of the greater illness. Corporate music not only sucks, but is becoming alarmingly less musical with each passing year. Eminem lip-synched during his SNL performance the week following Simpson's and nobody batted an eyelid. It hardly seems to matter; the performances are so homogenized, how can you possibly tell the difference?
"Must Simpson bear the cross alone, while all the entertainment world goes free?" Moody asks. Hardly. She's only being ridiculed because she got caught, and it was graceless, ugly and pathetic. She's young, she can take it. Since when does being a celebrity place you above ridicule? Mark my words, the publicity will do wonders for her career in a society lacking in taste, common sense and accountability.